Skip to main content

Milk Street Q&A

A community kitchen for bold flavors and big questions.

Ask a Question

Don’t have an account?Sign up

General

Asked Jan 21, 2025 by Jennae F.

Why Toasted Oat and Maple Scones Turn Out Too Wet and Too Sweet

I have made a number of recipes from the "Milk Street Bakes" book with great success, but I'm having trouble with the Toasted Oat and Maple Scones. I have made it twice, and both times found the scones overly sweet with a wet batter that was prone to spreading. I weigh everything in grams and chilled the scones for the full hour recommended. Love the concept of this recipe and want to give it another try, but I want to check if I'm making a mistake. It calls for 1/4 cup maple syrup with the oats, another 1/4 cup syrup in the buttermilk, and 1/3 cup white sugar in the dry ingredients. Is that correct? I have a sweet tooth, but the amount of sweetener seems very high compared to the other sweet ginger and chocolate scone recipe in the same book.

Answered by Elizabeth Mindreau

Hello Jennae – We are sorry that the Toasted Oat and Maple Scone recipe has not met your expectations. I discussed your questions with the developer of this recipe, here are her thoughts and suggestions: • she said that these scones do have a wetter batter than a typical scone and that they do tend to spread a bit. They will not be as firm and dry as a Starbucks kind of scone. What you described is ok and expected for this recipe. • she is wondering if you used real buttermilk, powdered buttermilk or a buttermilk substitute (milk + lemon juice). She said that real buttermilk is thick and rich and will hold the batter together whereas powdered butter or the substitute would be very watery and contribute a looser batter • As far as the sweetness of the scones, she said you could reduce the amount of maple syrup that is mixed with the buttermilk Please let us know how they turn out if you make these again.

Read More
Cookware

Asked Jan 20, 2025 by Sheree N.

Best Small Milk Street Knife for Peeling and Light Prep

Hello - The two knives I have from Milk Street are the Nakiri and the bread knife. Next, I'd like something small that is versatile to peel and do small chopping jobs. Would that be the Kitchen-kiji? Or - to rephrase - what are the uses of the kiji?

Answered by Elizabeth Mindreau

Hello Sheree – Thank you for your previous purchase of Milk Street knives, we appreciate it. The Kitchen-kiji is a small paring knife with a 3.5-inch blade. This would be good for hand peeling and as it says on our website, "It’s perfect for all the “in-between” jobs, small enough for detailed handwork like slicing garlic and shallots, trimming mushrooms or cutting fruit." It would also be good for small chopping jobs. The Small Nakiri has a 4.5-inch blade and would great for small slicing and chopping jobs, but not for peeling. The universal magnetic knife protector will fit your bread knife. Thanks again!

Read More
Milk Street Recipes

Asked Jan 14, 2025 by James M.

Where Did the Original Short Rib Ragu with Pappardelle Recipe Go

I had added a recipe to my Favorites, a recipe for Short Rib Bolognese that was pressure cooked. Where did that recipe go? I can no longer find it. This recipe called for fennel and a rind of Parmigiano-Reggiano, red wine with cubed carrots added toward the end. Did your company take that down from your recipes so that it could be included in the upcoming Italian cook book?

Answered by Elizabeth Mindreau

Hello James, That sounds like our One-Pot Short Rib Ragù with Pasta recipe.

Read More
General

Asked Jan 13, 2025 by Alexander H.

Looking for a Good Recipe for Liege Waffles

Does anyone have a good recommendation or source for a liege style waffle? I have tried a few online, but all turn out very dense.

Answered by Elizabeth Mindreau

Hello Alexander– We have not developed a recipe at Milk Street but I did find one in a book in our office library. It is from the 2019 edition of the "Joy of Cooking" on page 644. It uses a brioche recipe (page 603) and pearl sugar. Perhaps you can find the book at your local library.

Read More
Products

Asked Jan 10, 2025 by Sonya W.

Will Milk Street Bring Back Its House Spice Blends

Hello! I really miss the milk brand spice packets that used to be available in the milk street store. I loved knowing I could get excellent quality spices at reasonable prices. I especially liked your zaatar and sumac. Will you ever bring back your brand? Thank you very much.

Answered by Elizabeth Mindreau

Hello Sonya – Thank you for your interest in Milk Street spices blends, we truly appreciate it. I'm afraid that we no longer carry them, however, we are very happy to be working with the amazing Villa Jerada. They are the spice merchants who supply the za'atar and sumac we carry in the Milk Street store. We do have a Milk Street flavor-enhancer that adds umami to called Flavor Jolt, "a seasoning blend that elevates and amplifies the distinct flavor of anything you put it on." We have also brought back the Milk Street coffee sugars in a four-pack or individual flavors. Thank you again, The Milk Street Team

Read More
Milk Street Recipes

Asked Jan 06, 2025 by Alison N.

Menu Ideas for Guests with Fish, Gluten, Garlic and Onion Restrictions

I am hosting a party for a group of friends who combined are allergic/unable to eat: fish and shellfish, gluten, garlic, onions.... yikes! any suggestions? I'm thinking pork or chicken....but looking for something interesting. Thanks!

Answered by Elizabeth Mindreau

Hello Alison, Wow! You are a brave friend to try to accommodate so many different dietary needs at once. At Milk Street, we are not equipped to offer dietary recommendations. But, based on dodging allergens, it sounds like roasted pork or chicken with roasted or steamed vegetables or a tossed salad (with some nuts for crunch or gluten free croutons) are nice options. We have a chicken salmoriglio recipe that is full of flavor and served on a bed of watercress or arugula. Just omit the garlic. We have a variety of pork tenderloin recipes, Pork tenderloins with fig-olive relish is a popular one. again, leave out the garlic. Again, we are not authorities on specific dietary needs. Read all labels for allergen contents. It's also a good idea to have printed recipes of everything you make on hand as well as the containers of the ingredients you use in case any of your friends need to check for allergens. Good luck!

Read More
General

Asked Jan 03, 2025 by Dan S.

When Milk Street Magazine Issues Become Available on the Website

When is a given issue of the magazine available on the website. Today (1/3/25) I looke for a recipe from the Jan. Feb. 25 issue and it is not on the site. (I wanted to print a hard copy.) Thank you for your reply! Dan

Answered by Elizabeth Mindreau

Hello Dan, The recipes for a given issue of the magazine should be available on the website by the time the magazine is shipped to readers. Which recipe are you looking for?

Read More