BakingAsked Nov 08, 2023 by Chelsea W.
No matter what I do, I just can't seem to bake a good loaf of homemade bread anymore. I used to be able to, but I have tried dozens of times over the last couple of years and my loaves either come out flat, dry, and dense, or gummy, or excessively airy yet still dry. I have Googled everything you could possibly Google - rise times, temperatures, kneading, etc. I know that my bread is either vastly overproofed or significantly underproofed, and I just can't seem to knead it properly. It is either too much or too little. I have read about the window pane stage with dough, but never seem to get my dough that smooth and stretchy to achieve said stage. My house is colder, so I know that is part of the issue. I try to create warm places for the dough to rise, but perhaps I am making them too warm? I just want to be able to bake yummy loaves of bread with which I can make my children's sandwiches with! (Probably should have lead with that. It is a white sandwich loaf that I am trying to bake.) If there is an easier loaf recipe or more fool proof, please, let me in on the secret. My recipe is as follows:
2 cups warm water (no warmer than 110d)
2/3 cup white sugar
1/4 vegetable oil
1 tsp salt
2 tbsp active dry yeast
6 cups of flour (I use all purpose)
Help!
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi Chelsea -
Without seeing the whole recipe it's hard to fully troubleshoot your recipe, but we do think there is too much sugar in this recipe. 2/3 cup of sugar is a LOT - most recipes call for about 2 tablespoons of sugar. Too much sugar can inhibit or even kill the yeast by making the yeast produce too much alcohol. Yeast can tolerate just a certain amount of alcohol. So, the sugar will not kill yeast directly.
Sugar and yeast both need water content in your dough. If you add too much sugar that competition can go wrong. The dough will rise too slowly or not at all because the sugar is absorbing all the available water. At first, it may seem like you simply need more water, but unfortunately, the dough is a little more complicated than that. The most straightforward solutions are using a recipe with less sugar or adding more yeast. We would probably recommend the former. Have you tried our recipe for Japanese Milk Bread? If you'd prefer to try a different recipe, we always recommend using a recipe from a well-tested, reliable source such as a cookbook, food magazine, or food section of a newspaper. Many recipes online are not tested and, therefore, a recipe for failure (pun intended).
Lastly, we would probably also recommend a recipe with some milk or egg in it and butter in place of oil. All of these changes will add richness and flavor to prevent the dough from being dry and dull-tasting.
Best,
The Milk Street Cooking Team
Read More BakingAsked Sep 15, 2023 by Marla G.
I'm baking a honey cake. The recipe calls for 3/4 cup of red wine. I completely forgot to add it. Will it come out OK, if a little dry? Or will there be more dire consequences as a result of leaving out the alcohol?
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi Marla -
In addition to, obviously, changing the flavor of the cake, you're correct that it will affect the moisture of the cake since the wine is part of the liquid ingredients in the batter. The alcohol doesn't serve any purpose in the cake from a technical perspective.
Best,
The Milk Street Cooking Team
Read More BakingAsked Sep 11, 2023 by Joanne G.
Is it OK to substitute lard for some of the butter in your pie crust?
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi Joanne -
We didn't test lard in our Single-Crust Pie Dough, so we don't know for sure if/how it will work, though we presume a half-or-less substitution should be fine. If you do try it, make sure to find good quality rendered leaf lard, which is a bit hard to find. Much of the lard widely available in grocery stores has been hydrogenated and filled with preservatives, with a strong piggy flavor, which makes baking with it considerably less desirable than an all-butter crust.
Good luck!
Best,
The Milk Street Cooking Team
Read More BakingAsked Aug 30, 2023 by Cheryl M.
Hello,
Ive noticed in some of the cake recipes, salted butter is used. I have only used sweet butter in my cakes, so am curious if using the American Salted Butter will change the taste in the cakes? Specifically the Lemon Almond Pound Cake.
Thanks in advance for your response.
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi Cheryl -
Many chefs and bakers believe that using unsalted butter will allow you to control the salt content in your dishes better than using salted butter. But we've tested salted versus unsalted butter in a number of savory and baking recipes and we didn’t find any measurable difference between the two. The small amount of salt in salted butter (it's about 1/4 teaspoon per stick, depending on the brand) is undetectable when cooked or baked in a recipe, we found.
Still, we have a preference between the two. Though most culinary professionals and publications will recommend using unsalted butter, we prefer the salted kind because it tastes better when you’re not cooking with it. Unsalted butter doesn’t cut it on toast! Since we prefer to stick with one kind, salted butter is our choice. It also has a longer shelf life. So if you don’t go through butter at a fast rate, buying salted butter is a good idea.
You can certainly still use unsalted butter in our recipes if you prefer. You just may need to adjust the salt to your personal tastes. Using salted butter in the lemon almond pound cake will not make the cake salty, it will just give it a more rounded, deeper flavor.
Hope that helps!
The Milk Street Cooking Team
Read More BakingAsked Aug 14, 2023 by Ginny C.
Hello! I love that you did the article about pies from Yelapa. I've been there and eaten the "Pie Woman's" pies! They're amazing!
The pie that my family loves, though, is the coconut pies. Is there any chance you have the recipe for that one?
Thank you,
Ginny Christensen
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi Ginny -
This is the recipe we developed based on the coconut pie we had in Yelapa.
Best,
The Milk Street Cooking Team
Read More BakingAsked Jul 27, 2023 by John G.
For all of the baking recipes on Milk Street, should we assume that all of the cake/loaf pans and pie plates are metal and not glass? Most of my pie plates are glass so I would probably need to adjust temp/bake time if the recipe was designed for metal.
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi John -
For loaf and tart pans, you can assume metal. For pie plates we prefer glass. Glass heats up gently and evenly, priming the pie for a consistent, but slightly slower bake. It also provides an easy window into doneness, which ensures that the pie dough is completely cooked. For 9x13 baking pans we generally specify if it’s necessary for the pan to be metal and, otherwise, either glass or metal should work. Just keep in mind that glass heats up more slowly so cooking times may be on the higher end of a range.
Hope that helps!
Best,
The Milk Street Cooking Team
Read More BakingAsked Jun 14, 2023 by Steve K.
I was making a rhubarb scone recipe that did not call for any eggs, just 1 1/4 cup heavy cream.
I wanted the rising effect of an egg so I attempted to reduce the amount of cream by adding 1 egg. The other change , I substituted light cream for the heavy cream volume.
When I mixed the wet with the dry it became batter, I was forced to add an additional 3/4 of a cup of flour to get it to a workable dough consistency.
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi Steve -
We aren’t sure of your question - are you asking why it turned into batter?
This is likely because you made two changes to the recipe. First, in order to replace some of the cream with egg you would’ve needed to measure the amount of cream you removed by volume or weight and replace with the exact same amount of egg to ensure the texture of the dough would be the same. Second, you used light cream instead of heavy cream. Light cream contains less milk fat that heavy cream (18-30% vs. at least 36%). The more milk fat, the thicker the cream, and the less water in the product. This would definitely make the dough more loose.
Hope that helps!
The Milk Street Cooking Team
Read More BakingAsked Jun 12, 2023 by Gail L.
Is there any reason not to julienne the orange peel before making the syrup, rather than at the end? It would be much easier and give a neater result.
Cake is delicious and got rave reviews.
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi Gail -
We are so glad you enjoyed the bete noire!
The pieces of zest are meant to be very finely sliced for serving. We chose to cook the zest in larger strips (and then slice after sugaring) to prevent the zest from falling apart during candying.
Best,
The Milk Street Cooking Team
Read More BakingAsked May 31, 2023 by Linda R.
I’ve heard that the oven temperature needs to be adjusted when using non-stick and/or dark bakeware. I have a springform pan that is both non-stick and dark. Do I need to adjust the temperature to ensure even baking and prevent over-baking? If so, what is the formula? For example, if the recipes calls for 350 degrees, what should I set it at? And should I adjust the baking time as well?
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi Linda -
A dark metal pan absorbs and distributes heat more quickly and thoroughly than lighter-colored pans. So not only does your cake bake more quickly in a dark pan, its crust can potentially burn (or at least brown unpleasantly) due to over-exposure to oven heat.
Therefore, you should lower the temperature by 25 degrees and start checking you baked goods about 10 minutes before the times specified in the recipe.
Best,
The Milk Street Cooking Team
Read More BakingAsked Apr 28, 2023 by Leta D.
I have found a recipe for quick bread that includes shredded coconut. The wet ingredients include milk. I have a can of coconut milk and was thinking of substituting that for cow's milk. Does anyone have an idea of how that might affect the results? The dry ingredients are flour, baking powder, salt, and sugar. The wet are 1 egg, vanilla, and milk. You stir in the unsweetened coconut flakes with the milk.
Answered by Lynn Clark
Hi Leta -
You should be able to replace the milk with coconut milk. Just make sure the can in well blended before using it in your recipe. You can sub 1:1 for the milk.
Best,
The Milk Street Team
Read More