Skip to main content
French Toast, Perfected

French Toast, Perfected

By Milk StreetApril 8, 2025

  • Makes
    4 servings
  • Cook Time
    45 minutes
  • Rating

This recipe delivers thick slabs of French toast that are crispy outside, yet rich and custardy at the center, but without any sogginess. For plush, tender French toast, challah is best; for a heartier texture, opt for a batard-shaped Italian bread with a sturdy, rustic crumb (look for a loaf about 6 inches wide by 4 inches high). Whichever you use, cut 1-inch-thick slices from the center, if possible. Lightly toasting the bread until dry on the surface but not browned is essential for proper absorption (alternatively, allow the slices to dry overnight, uncovered, on a wire rack). The surprise ingredient is semolina. A couple tablespoons in the egg-milk soak adds just the right amount of starch so the bread does not become limp and structureless at the center. Sugar sprinkled onto the surface of the soaked slices just before butter-frying yields crisp caramelization. Maple syrup is our favorite accompaniment, along with fresh berries.

Tip

Don’t use the soaking mixture right away. Allow it to stand for at least 10 minutes so the semolina hydrates and the sugar fully dissolves. When dipping the bread, soak challah for 10 minutes and Italian bread for 15 minutes, flipping the slices halfway through. There will be very little liquid left in the baking dish.

To access this recipe, you need to be a member.

Join Milk Street and get instant access to over 3,500 recipes for just $1.

© 177 Milk Street. All rights reserved.