Best Way to Cook a Lean Eye of Round Roast

Question

Hello,
I've got a grass fed eye of round roast that I expect to be on the tough side, and I want to tame it in my instant pot.  Can you recommend a recipe?  Or maybe cooking time adjustments to make to a recipe for a more tender cut?
Thanks!

Lynn Clark · Accepted Answer

Hi Susan - I'm not sure what to recommend since I'm not sure what your end goal is - are you trying to make a pot roast from an eye of round roast? Unfortunately, we don't have any recipes using eye of round in the Instant Pot. That's likely because we usually prefer fattier, long-cooking cuts for the pressure cooker. Eye of round is very lean and works best when cooked like a roast and served thinly sliced. I would recommend salting and refrigerating the meat about 24 hours in advance and then cooking it low and slow using the reverse-sear method - Cook the roast in a low oven (250-275) until it's almost to medium-rare (or your preferred roast beef temperature) then remove it and brown it on all sides on the stovetop. Good luck! Best, Lynn C.

Best Way to Cook a Lean Eye of Round Roast

Have a question for Milk Street experts?

Join the conversation