I'm a first time Sourdough Starter maker. I'm on Day 2 - its looking bubbly! I fed it once already and according to my recipe, I will be feeding it everyday for 5 days. My question is: Some recipes say to remove some of the "starter" each day and throw away, and then feed. My recipe doesn't suggest this. What is the difference and is it important to chuck some everyday before the daily feed? Thanks!
Have a question for Milk Street experts?
Get trusted advice from the cooks, editors, and recipe developers behind Milk Street.
Don’t have an account?Sign up
Join the conversation
Sign in to join the conversation.
COMMENTS
Annie H.
April 7, 2020
Hi Lori! I think you do, in fact, need to throw away some of your starter every day. I know, it feels wasteful! But, the yeast “eat” all of the fresh flour when you feed it, and they need new food to eat to keep them bubbling, happy, and alive. I think you throw some away because you need a certain proportion of starter, water, and fresh flour (2oz of water and starter, 2.5oz if flour is my go to!) if you don’t throw away some starter, your new pet will just grow and grow until it is huge!!! I would continue to feed it everyday for a few weeks until it seems stable. At that point, it can live in the fridge and you can just feed it once a week. I have also found some recipes that use the starter discard, if you’re worried about the waste of throwing away the exhausted starter. A favorite of my is a crumpet recipe! Good luck with your project!!